Address: Somewhere in Gramercy Park
Nestled in the Gramercy Park Historical District, Pete’s Tavern is a living relic of New York City’s storied past, proudly wearing its title as “the Tavern that O. Henry made famous.” This iconic establishment, dating back to 1829, has seen more than its fair share of history, including a Civil War-era transformation into one of the city’s most beloved bars in 1864. Though its claim as the oldest bar in the city is hotly contested by McSorley’s, Pete’s Tavern remains a cornerstone of New York’s vibrant past. During Prohibition, business carried on as usual under the clever guise of a flower shop, a nod to the tavern’s resilience and creativity. While it may not have an official landmark status, its place in the hearts of New Yorkers is undeniable, making Pete’s Tavern a true classic in every sense.